The Tour Trains
History and Hokum

|
A postcard
view of the "Last Chancer" tour train at the Veterans
and Pioneers Memorial Building, late 1950s. The tour train was
created in 1954 under the auspices of "Helena, Unlimited",
a not-for-profit corporation organized by the Helena Chamber
of Commerce.
An
updated " Last Chancer" still operates today, taking
passengers on a narrated tour of Helena's historic sites. A second train was added in 1993. The Last Chancer
Tour Train website.
The information presented on the tours is a mix of factual history, inaccurate history, and tall tales that the drivers make up.
The veracity problem has been ongoing for a very long time, despite efforts by local historians (including the late Ellen Baumler) to correct it. Consequently, thousands of tourists come away with false impressions of the city. Helena's colorful history does not need embellishment, and the facts are easy to find.
The falsehoods and misrepresentations are many, but one whopper that persists on the tour is that Benton Avenue was the terminus of the Benton Road, the overland wagon route that connected Helena with St. Louis, Missouri, via the river port of Fort Benton, Montana. The claim is made that Benton Ave. was the main freight route into town, ending at Reeder's Alley, and that the stone Benton Ave. retaining wall above Park Avenue was built for that purpose. The truth is that Benton Avenue was never part of the Benton Road, no wagon freight came in that way, for obvious logistical reasons. The retaining wall was built in 1893, a decade after rail service came to Helena.
Tour train drivers have also presented as fact a version of the unproven story that a World War II pilot flew a fighter plane between the spires of the Cathedral of Saint Helena.
Also, the replica of the Liberty Bell
on the Capitol campus was not, contrary to what the driver might tell you, cast at the same foundry that made the Statue of Liberty -- which wasn't even cast.
Thomas Francis Meagher (the figure on the equestrian statue in front of the Capitol building), did not design the flag of Ireland.
The list goes on and on.
There were apparently even wilder tales in the past -- public hangings on the courthouse lawn, underground labyrinths of Chinese tunnels with opium dens.
Such hooey is harmless enough if it is presented as being just tall tales, but it is typically presented as historical fact. Plus, the tour train is headquarted at the Montana Historical Society, which gives an unearned endorsement to the material presented on the tours. One important consideration is that groups of school children are taken on the tours, and they should be told the truth.
We can only speculate why train drivers tell these tales. One motivation might be to put on a memorable show for the patrons, with hopes of good tips at the end of the tours. Unfortunately, Helena's history ends up getting short-changed.
|
|
|
|
A city-wide
contest was held in June of 1954 to name the train, which was
at first little more than a gold-painted jeep pulling three
cars. Some of the names suggested were "Sacajawea",
"Gulch Express" and "The Six Shooter". The
maiden run of "The Last Chancer" (winning name submitted
by Mrs. S. J. Zahara) occured on June 15, 1954. For several
years, tours began at the Great Northern depot (now demolished),
at the intersection of Neill Ave. and Fuller.
During the
winter of 1954-55, the jeep was upgraded to look like a locomotive
at the State Training School in Boulder. It was designed by
Harold Jensen and executed by Clem LaVinge.
|
|
|

PHOTO
COURTESY OF KATHRYN
FEHLIG CLICK PHOTO
FOR A LARGE VERSION IN A NEW WINDOW
|
Publicity
photo of the first Last Chancer, taken at the Old Brewery Theater,
June 14 1954. This was the day before the official inaugural
run of the Tour Train. Seated on the train are numerous local
notables of the day, including Montana Governor J. Hugo Aronson
behind the wheel.
The
train made its maiden run the following day with H. S. "Hi"
Dotson, Norman B. Holter, Mr. and Mrs. A. T. Hibbard, Mr. and
Mrs. Marc Buterbaugh, Fred Heinecke, George Vucanovich, Vernon
Cougill, Mr. and Mrs. John Quigley, James Dion, Harold L Paulsen,
P. W. Singer, Neil MacLean, C. F. Mueller, Larry Graham, Mrs.
Sherman W. Smith, Eugene Fehlig, John G. Thompson, Clem Meyer
and Bryant B. Anderson aboard.
|
The
Original Last Chancer
Park Ave. at N eill Ave., 1954

COURTESY
OF DICK MORTIEAU CLICK ON PHOTO TO ENLARGE IN A NEW WINDOW
The
Original Last Chancer on Neill Avenue, 1954

COURTESY
OF DICK MORTIEAU CLICK ON PHOTO TO ENLARGE IN A NEW WINDOW
The
Original Last Chancer on Neill Avenue, 1954

COURTESY
OF DICK MORTIEAU CLICK ON PHOTO TO ENLARGE IN A NEW WINDOW
The
Revamped Last Chancer on Neill Avenue, 1955
Monty and Marnette Cowles

COURTESY
OF MARNETTE COWLES PHILLIPS CLICK ON PHOTO TO ENLARGE IN A NEW WINDOW
The
Last Chancer at Hill Park, 1956

COLLECTION
OF KENNON BAIRD CLICK ON PHOTO TO ENLARGE IN A NEW WINDOW
| The driver has been identified as Dorothy Virginia Dotson (1906-1990) |
The
Last Chancer at Hill Park, June 24 1957
Photos by Jean O'Blenis

COLLECTION
OF KENNON BAIRD CLICK ON PHOTO FOR A
BIG VERSION IN A NEW WINDOW

COLLECTION OF KENNON BAIRD
CLICK ON PHOTO FOR A BIG VERSION IN A NEW WINDOW
Postcard View of the Last Chancer
on Fuller Ave., 1956

The
Last Chancer at The Old Brewery Theater, June 24 1957
Photo by Jean O'Blenis

COLLECTION
OF KENNON BAIRD
CLICK ON PHOTO FOR A BIG VERSION IN A NEW WINDOW
Second Train Added, 1993

CLICK ON PHOTO TO ENLARGE IN A NEW WINDOW

|